Are the bond markets and rating agencies to be feared?

5th January, 2010

There has been much sturm and drang generated by the Guardian and others on the threat posed to government finances by the flawed and often irrational rating agencies, and by the supposedly despotic, vengeful and greedy bond markets.

Methinks they protest too much.

We at the Green New Deal group have long argued that there is no reason why governments should rely for their financing on the capricious private bond markets. Instead, we write in ‘The Cuts Won’t Work’ –  finance ministers should oblige the banks in which taxpayers have a substantial stake to lend to the Treasury at very low rates of interest.

That’s how World War II was largely financed in Britain – and no one was the worse for it. The loans were given a title: Treasury Deposit Receipts.  These TDRs – bless them – financed a war that saved Britain from the threat Nazism posed to its very existence. Today they could be used to finance the public investment needed to substitute for the collapse in private investment – and to stave off the threat posed by climate change.

Analysts on the Financial Times Lex column (FT 1st January, 2010) have obviously read our latest report, and describe our proposal as “an intriguing alternative” . Governments they write “may lean on the commercial banks in which they hold large stakes to take up the strain instead. Forcing them to purchase government bonds would help replace the market heft of central banks.”

Quite so. You read it first in the Green New Deal.

Share on FacebookShare on Google+Tweet about this on TwitterShare on LinkedInEmail this to someonePrint this page

3 comments to Are the bond markets and rating agencies to be feared?

  • […] Ann Pettifor has written: There has been much sturm and drang generated by the Guardian and others on the threat

    posed to government finances by the flawed and often irrational rating agencies, and by the supposedly despotic, vengeful and greedy bond markets.

    […]

  • […] Ann Pettifor has written: There has been

    much sturm and drang generated by the Guardian and others on the threat posed to government finances by the flawed and often irrational rating

    agencies, and by the supposedly despotic, vengeful and greedy bond markets. […]

  • Ken MacIntyre

    Correct.

    What are these ‘bond markets’ (ditto for rating agencies) which subvert democratic government other than a deceitful

    euphemism for the financial oligarchy which has hijacked governments and regulators and got us into a debt-laden mess? All the government has to do

    to finance its requirements is to make the Bank of England create new money and lend at zero or 1%, or spend it directly into the economy. But can

    the government do this asked a friend when I mentioned this – of course it can. That is what is there for. Anything less is an abrogation of

    sovereignty.

Leave a Reply

You can use these HTML tags

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>